the weblog of Alan Knox

Knowing Jesus in the Breaking of the Bread

Posted by on Jan 26, 2010 in books, ordinances/sacraments | 2 comments

Today’s ordinary Catholic mass or mainline Protestant communion service bears little resemblance to what we can glean from the New Testament about the first celebrations of Jesus’ presence in the breaking of the bread. Arguments that have divided denominations over the question of the relationship between the blessed bread and the whereabouts of Jesus would certainly have seemed strange and irrelevant to the first ekklÄ“siai. The New Testament speaks simply, both in the Gospels and in other writings, of memory and presence without theological elaboration. Because of our modern historical obsession with what one might call “left-brain” (rational) inquiries about a “right-brain” (affective) experience, we have often lost the essence of what Jesus intended and Paul understood about the Eucharist. (Wes Howard-Brook, The Church Before Christianity, New York: Orbis Books, 2004, p. 50)

Is the author correct? Would our arguments and disagreements concerning “The Lord’s Supper” or “The Eucharist” or “Communion” seem strange and irrelevant to the first churches? Are they, in fact, irrelevant today?


2 Comments

Comments are closed. If you would like to discuss this post, send an email to alan [at] alanknox [dot] net.

  1. 1-26-2010

    I think the author is correct and going further I don’t think it would be a stretch to say that someone from the first churches would have no idea what is going on in most of our “worship services”. Having said that, I think that the disagreement over the Roman “Eucharist” and the issue of transubstantiation is very much a relevant issue today.

  2. 1-27-2010

    This is not a thread hijack. But Alan. I wrote something today YOU could do much better on. I will link to this post. Hope you will do something with how far we have drifted.